A man accused of brutal rape and manslaughter on Lynette Daily appeals conviction

She didn’t complain about the pain and thought the blood was menstruation, he said.

Atwater told police that Ms. Daily had collapsed while swimming at dawn. Maris called Triple Zero after 6am. I heard Atwater taunting his unresponsive girlfriend. By the time the ambulance arrived, she was blue, cold, and rigor mortis had begun.

Meanwhile, Maris was burning a blood-covered mattress and clothes. He claimed that the crown was also interpreted as a lie because it “smelled”.

Adrian Atwater (left) and Paul Maris argue for their belief in the death of Lynette Daily.

Ms. Manuel said that Judge Fullerton initially described Atwater’s police as “an integrated course of intentional lies intended to hide what he knew” and “irrational stories.” He therefore said he allowed the crown to characterize as evidence of his guilt.

However, the ruling was later revoked. Rather than being admitted as evidence of Atwater’s guilt, his apparent lies could only be used against his credibility as a witness.


At that point, Manuel left the impression in the judge’s mind that the previous ruling had already put the defense counsel at a disadvantage, and it was impossible to “scramble the egg” at a later direction. Said there was.

“The problem was that there was a mix of messages that must have confused the jury so that it wouldn’t end. I’ll submit it,” Manuel said.

“Given they were out for only 32 minutes, I can guess that this issue didn’t cause much concern to them, but it should be in my submission.”

Convicted of daily manslaughter and exacerbation of sexual assault, Atwater was subsequently sentenced to 19 years in prison with a parole of 14 years. Maris was sentenced to nine years on parole for six years and nine months for worsening sexual assault and obstructing police investigations.

In addition to the instructions given to the jury, men have appealed their convictions because the verdict was unreasonable or was not supported by evidence.

“Mostly contextual cases,” Manuel said, “there was a very high risk for the jury to file a proceeding based on the suspicious facts overwhelmed by emotions.”

She knows the degree of addiction to Ms. Daily, whether she has the ability to agree to sexual intercourse, and if not, whether her client knows she does not agree, and he knows I was aware of the seriousness of her injuries, which she said left considerable doubt as to whether she was.

The appeal continues.

Get the Morning & Evening Edition Newsletter

Jenny Noyes is a journalist at The Sydney Morning Herald.

Most viewed in the whole country


A man accused of brutal rape and manslaughter on Lynette Daily appeals conviction

Source link A man accused of brutal rape and manslaughter on Lynette Daily appeals conviction

Back to top button