Beware of A2 Milk (NZSE ) and Its Capital Returns

If you’re seeking a high-growth investment opportunity, there are key factors to consider. Firstly, a proven trend of increasing Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) is crucial, indicating efficient reinvestment of earnings into the business. Secondly, the expansion of capital employed should support sustained growth. However, upon initial analysis, it appears that a2 Milk (NZSE: ATM) may not exhibit the potential to become a multi-bagger in the future. Here’s why:

Return On Capital Employed (ROCE): Understanding Its Significance

ROCE measures a company’s ability to generate pre-tax profits from the capital invested in its operations. For a2 Milk, the calculation is as follows:

Based on the trailing twelve months to December 2023, a2 Milk’s ROCE stands at 17%. While this figure is satisfactory in absolute terms, it significantly exceeds the Food industry average of 9.7%.

Reviewing a2 Milk’s Performance

Comparing current ROCE with historical data reveals a declining trend, dropping from 56% over the past five years. Moreover, despite increased capital investment, there hasn’t been a corresponding rise in sales, suggesting these investments may be long-term strategies requiring more time to yield returns.

Final Assessment

In conclusion, while a2 Milk continues to reinvest in its business, diminishing returns raise concerns. The stock has also declined by 53% over the last five years, indicating market skepticism about future growth. Considering these factors, we remain cautious about its growth prospects compared to other potential multi-bagger opportunities.

For those still interested in a2 Milk, exploring its intrinsic value and current trading price may provide additional insights into its investment potential.

Back to top button