Billionaire Clive Palmer failed in his final bid to delay confronting the courtroom until the state border opened due to an imminent lawsuit over the use of Twisted Sister’s 80’s classics. “We’re not going to take it” With campaign ads.
A businessman and former politician has been sued by Universal Music, and the hearing will begin seven days later.
But federal court heard on Monday that he didn’t want to provide evidence of the video conference because he was unaware of the amount of cases he was directed to attacking his credibility.
In return, the judge said that “only the idiots” would have thought it was not a problem.
Palmer’s barrister, Paddy Williams, told the court that his client “wants to expose himself to the rigors of cross-examination,” but traveling on the interstate highway in the COVID-19 pandemic. The difficulty means that it is not easy.
Williams said Palmer could travel to New South Wales but “must be quarantined for two weeks” when he returned to Queensland. This is a test that “clearly outweighs” the inconvenience to Universal Music caused by the postponement of the trial.
Judge Katzman said he didn’t think the Microsoft team would put Palmer at a disadvantage.
“It’s easy to assess their attitude in many ways when someone is in front of me when the witness is on the screen. Recent attitudes apply to anything.” She said.
Universal Music’s deputy Patrick Flynn said it was “unbelievable” that Palmer could be thought of as limiting more attacks on his credibility.
He pointed out that the document submitted by Universal specifically stated that he rejected Mr. Palmer’s claim that the music was used for parody or satire.
“There is no doubt that Mr. Palmer’s credibility was a problem from the beginning. Only fools thought about anything else,” Judge Katzman said.
Palmer’s application quotes a media release from Queensland Prime Minister Anastasia Parasekuk on October 2, saying that the border will resume after 28 days in New South Wales without a locally infected mystery case. Stated.
“Everything becomes speculative” when trying to predict when this will happen, and “the clock suddenly returns to zero” in the event of an incident, Flynn said.
Judge Katzman agreed, “We can’t postpone it to another date because we don’t know what’s going on in the next one, six, or twelve months.”
As soon as Williams finished his reply, Judge Katzman said: “I have not been persuaded to cancel the hearing or postpone part of the hearing. Can you tell me why?”
“Give me your honor. I have been instructed to take a reason,” Williams said.
“Then I’ll explain why at some point tomorrow,” she replied.
Williams then said he was instructed to appeal the decision.
“I haven’t even given my reason!” Said Judge Katzman.
She refused to allow her decision to stay and told Williams that she could apply for a vacation to appeal if she wished even after reading her reasons.
Mr Palmer offered to pay the relevant costs if the trial was delayed, or even his evidence alone. He also had to pay for the application.
The trial is scheduled to begin on October 19.
Originally published as “Fool Only”: Judge Knockback Clive
Clive Palmer, Twisted Sister: Millionaires Don’t Win Delay in Copyright Proceedings
Source link Clive Palmer, Twisted Sister: Millionaires Don’t Win Delay in Copyright Proceedings