fireThere are many documentaries about the brutal division of India It opened with an RP accent that uttered a variation of nostalgia-scented sentiment: “India was the jewel in the crown…”? India 1947: Partition in Color (Channel 4) also begins with these words. But the tone of this tense, raging two-part of his is different. This is not only because archival footage has been colorized for the first time. More than color, it is full of clear truth. Especially the dignified anger that comes from 75 years of watching my painful history be co-opted, misrepresented and silenced.
With films, photographs, oral testimonies that will break your heart, private documents that fill you with rage, and some wonderful contributors, plus some needless reconstructions – India 1947: The Catastrophe of the 20th Century. On 20 February 1947, six months before the partition, the British appointed Lord Mountbatten as the last Governor-General of India. On 6 May 1947, with three months to go, Mountbatten’s Vulcan plan was approved in London. The on-screen countdown is claustrophobic and stressful. I agree. We’re talking about a small group of people who carved out one of the most diverse regions in the world in a matter of weeks. A tragic die roll that killed one million Indians and displaced nearly 15 million from their homes. Estimates are he’s 17 million, and he’s closer to 20 million).
Refreshingly, most of the speaking heads are Indians and Pakistanis. Lakshman Menon, professor, historian, author, and silver-tongued grandson of Vice President Menon, Mountbatten’s Chief of Staff. Everyone is very generous with their evaluation. Addressing Professor Priya Sathya of Stanford University for the fact that it took him five days for the British Governor of Bengal to deploy an army to quell the surge of violence that swept through Calcutta (now Kolkata) in August 1946. please. “It’s racist,” she says. points out that it originated from British colonial policy. “Literally, Indians are given freedom to kill each other,” she says. About Mountbatten’s quick decision to create two new nations of his own with different identities in just 10 weeks, broadcaster Anita Her Anand said:
I have a revelation. What became known as the Mountbatten Project was not his at all. It was Vice President Menon who quickly came up with the idea of transferring power to two nations instead of ten or more state governments. “As a matter of fact, Mountbatten had nothing to do with it,” says Lakshman Menon. VP Menon was awarded the highest level of knighthood on Mountbatten’s final honors list. “My grandfather declined very politely,” Lakshman says with a twinkle in his eye. “He later said to his daughter-in-law, my mother, ‘How can I accept a knighthood as the man who caused the division of our country?'” – rotates.
Then there was a troubled and politically favorable relationship between Mountbatten and his wife Edwina and the charismatic Indian National Congress leader Nehru, with whom she was rumored to be having an affair. I have. Andrew Lownie, author of The Mountbattens: Their Lives and Loves, presents it as a fact corroborated by Nehru’s diary. He also said the two may have been “through pulls.”
In any case, given Mountbatten’s impartial role, it was highly inappropriate. I met Nehru. they became famous. After all, Nehru, who immersed himself in teaching English, is ironically regarded as “the last British to rule India”. Both wanted a united India, but Jinnah, in the aftermath of World War II, demanded a homeland to save India’s Muslim minority for their own lives. In a confidential memo, Mountbatten admits that he “used his friendship with Nehru to get his personal opinion on the new draft”. He showed the draft to Nehru, but not to Jinnah. Historian Adeel Hussain says he has never seen a historical figure so often called a madman. [Jinnah’s] request, they are reasonable and sober. “
India, 1947 Part 2: The “Color Divider” covering the border drawn by Cyril Radcliffe, who has never visited India, uses details from the unpublished memoirs of private secretary Christopher Beaumont doing. This first part contains excerpts from Mountbatten’s diaries and letters “saved for the nation” in 2010. This is how the confidential partition remains after her 75 years. The documentary’s greatest power is to remind us how much we don’t know yet.
India 1947: Partition in Color Review – A Heartbreaking and Infuriating History of British Colonial Heritage | TV
Source link India 1947: Partition in Color Review – A Heartbreaking and Infuriating History of British Colonial Heritage | TV