The idea that public lands in the harbor benefit the public is generally ridiculed by those in the know in Sydney. Lip service may be paid by politicians, token gardens may be thrown in. During the Great Depression, Barangaroo’s marine foreshore was known as the Hungry Mile. It’s still an appropriate adjective. Unless you have a $200 lunch bill, his gas-hungry 4WD vehicle, and a jaundiced eye for natural beauty, you can walk there if security allows, and you’ll still starve to death. will be – Tim Mackenzie, Leichhardt
Perrotet’s view that barangaroo is a shining jewel suggests that he is blinded by the gaudy trifle that reflects the afternoon sun and shadows all the unfortunate life that dwells behind it. Casinos have been there forever, and Paul Keating’s vision of Arcadian is somewhat distorted (“A curse or a gift?”, October 17), but more disturbing is Perrottet’s statement that there is more “untapped potential” at Blackwattle Bay. – Brian Thornton, Stanmore
I strongly agree with Mark Tietjen (letter, October 17). All buildings around the Anzac Bridge should be limited to his 3-4 storeys. Look to great cities like Paris and Rome. Learn from the best. – Mary Porter, Watson’s Bay
Barangaroo failed. It bears no resemblance to the design of the winning Barangaroo South International Competition and completely ignores the Barangaroo Central Masterplan commissioned and approved by the NSW Government. – Harold Kerr, Miller’s Point
There is something tremendously bombastic about Keating’s site representation as an interface “between romanticism and enlightenment, between reason and passion.” His version of the vision is negated by the spectacle of a bulging casino building with unwieldy clusters of towers, a lack of interesting scale and proportions, and unexplained architecturally clumsy protrusions. This important building dedicated to represents the aesthetic and ethical downfall of Keating’s vision. – Ruth Wilson, Edgecliff
Perrottet speaks to Barangaroo by patronizing other cities and sneering, “Better not to say too much about Brisbane.” In a quiet and low-key way, Brisbane is now building a waterfront precinct that will kill Barangaroo. will show that – Grant Agnew, Cooper’s Plains (QLD)
What Perrottet’s government actually did was turn the ugly horizontal concrete slab into an even uglier vertical concrete slab. – Jeff Wannan, Dawes Point
Jack Lang gave us the Harbor Bridge. Joe Cahill gave us the Opera House. And Jack Mundy gave us The Rocks and many more. Keating can keep Barangaroo. What a disaster for Sydney Harbor. – Janet Turos, West Pymble
Mental Challenges for Politicians
“Finding new ways to talk about the breadth of being human is one of the challenges facing political leaders, whether they are aware of it or not.” In this quote, Sean Kelly (“find the lost soul of politics,” October 17) eloquently sums up the political challenge to politicians. Spirituality seems to be on the wane, especially among some politicians these days. For them, having a “spiritual” aspect has become a box-tic tool rather than a way of life. You have to be human. In fact, our political or public persona is an extension of our inner self and should be a consistent, honest, trustworthy and likeable persona. Politicians may not have all the answers, but they should be real people who always do the right thing for humanity. just like us. – Jeff Niron, Mascot
How nice it is to wake up and read something very sane and creative, especially the following sentences: If I were Prime Minister, I would put all politicians and staff to the test on Sean Kelly’s wonderful article. Graham Ellis, Narawena
I applaud Kelley for trying to bring emotion back into politics, but his arguments show shallowness of thought. Feelings of fear, invisible presence, and emptiness are chemical changes in the brain that trigger even if they are not immediately apparent. Judging right from wrong is an evolved survival mechanism that is often overridden by self-interest. Another survival mechanism. Not mysterious at all. – David McCarthy, Berowra
The kettle is black, says Pot
New South Wales Treasury Secretary Matt Keane must be joking (“Keane accuses Canberra of supporting the Labor State”, 17 October). Former Liberal Prime Minister Gladys Berejiklian argued that barrel-roasting pigs was fine, as everyone else does. – Sally Spar, Lane Cove
Keane is part of the Cabinet that blew a chance to claim an expansion of NSW infrastructure in the 2022 federal budget. During his 12 years in office, our state government has misunderstood what really contributes to healthy growth, income stability and green development, especially in areas like western Sydney. I was. There was an opportunity for a proper scientific discussion on alternatives to raising the walls of the Warragamba Dam, the real passenger demand expected at Western Sydney Airport, and the balance between public transport and toll roads. The state government and its ministers based in northern Sydney have avoided all these opportunities. – Don Morrison, Katoomba
The stars are too big to crush
I thought about the possibility of Star losing their casino license after the bad reports (“Star Fined $100 Million As New Chief’s First Day”, 17 October). But no (suspended), NSW coffers got her $100 million boost from its corrosive activity. LOSE YOUR LICENSE? About the same chance that the house will lose to a gullible punter. – Dick Clark, Elanora Heights
A $100 million fine is a good start, but will former casino executives face criminal charges? Rob Phillips, North Epping
A $100 million fine is substantial, but it does nothing to structurally change casinos’ tendency to foster corruption. Let’s hope we don’t get carried away with the income from heavy fines in the same way we do with gambling taxes. – Colin Stokes, Camperdown
First, fix the teacher workload
I do not consider the “five schools across the country” study to be a validation study (“Sharing lesson plans takes the burden off your shoulders”, 17 October). I’m retired and he’s four years old, but I’ve been doing stage planning and workshops every semester in elementary school for a few years before that, so the idea of the Grattan Institute isn’t new. Teachers should develop a wealth of resources that they can use as the basis of their teaching. State governments need to invest in different strategies to deal with teacher workload. Having a professional teacher librarian in each school, creating and curating high quality resources, and giving teachers time to collaborate on developing those resources and lessons are examples of what it takes. bank. – Sharon McGuinness, Thurroll
Lesson plans and “resource banks” for teachers are a good idea. The risk is forgetting that good education is less about what you teach and more about when and how you teach it. A dozen conductors can conduct a Beethoven symphony, but every note, pause, and pace are clearly designated, but only his two or his three make it shine. . Good teaching (and lesson planning) focuses less on choreography and film directing than on writing scripts and scores. – Peter Russell, Coogee
The foundation of good teaching and learning is experimentation, collaboration, and fine-tuning lesson plans to meet the needs of students in a particular school. According to the Grattan Institute, best teaching practices include using lessons that emphasize individual instruction. Contrary to the article, schools often work together to share lesson plans and programs and revise them annually. The “lessons shared” of that pandemic was an absolute disaster. – Vanessa Tennent, Autry
There is no need to buy “high-quality curriculum materials from overseas”. The teacher knows her school’s competent lesson planners and seeks access to those programs when she has to teach the material in the following year. High-quality materials produced by creative and experienced educators are used in many schools. These materials should be made available to other teachers who are less experienced or lack adequate resources. – Stephanie Harrison, Lane Cove
soon to be ex rex
The proposal to display endangered species on the five-dollar bill (letter, 17 October) may be an argument for portraying the King of Australia. – Rob Baxter, Narenburn
Why aren’t the former prime ministers depicted on Australian banknotes? When there is a requirement that a person must be dead for at least 30 years, there are still plenty of options. So isn’t it time for Sir Robert Menzies to triumph? Greg Cantoli, Kingsgrove
on his game
The powerful and emotional words of jockey Craig Williams cheering on the people of Ukraine after his Everest victory show that there is a new prince in the sport of kings (“He changed his life on Everest, but Williams’ real victory is saving them in Ukraine.” smh.com.au, 16 October). – Barry French, Cronulla
do not worry
Would more parental leave be good for the baby?“More vacation for new parents is also good for the economy.”, October 17). – Margaret Hodge, North Carl Carl
financial burden
A lot of people seem to be calling for a “overhaul” of the tax system. Why not 12 years ago he fully implemented the findings of the last review chaired by Dr. Ken Henry, and in many cases these reviews are a reason for doing nothing. – Charles Kent, Hunter’s Hill
digital view
Online comments from one of the stories with the most reader feedback on smh.com.au
“Gift or Curse? Keating’s Barangaroo Vision 10 Years Later“
from Aria: “Make it and they will come… The place is packed every time I go. On a sunny day, you can’t get a table in any of the restaurants. Not only tourists but also locals Popular with people and suburbs alike.Great combination of built environment and green space.Maybe it could have been better, but my realist is that there is so much green space and boardwalks Thank you. Enjoy!”
- to submit a letter to sydney morning heraldEmail letter@smh.com.au. Click here Tips on how to write letters.
- The Opinion Newsletter is a weekly wrap-up of views that challenge, defend and inform you. SIGN UP HERE.
Medicare is open to corruption from doctors and patients
Source link Medicare is open to corruption from doctors and patients