On Wednesday, the court heard that a deputy sergeant from the Melbourne Prosecutor’s Office contacted the woman on June 29 to tell her the charges were “fatally flawed” and would be dropped.
He also said that an internal investigation found that there were other cases that could be dismissed because they were based on faulty claims.
However, on 6 July, Anthony Alboa, the chief attorney for Victoria Police, wrote to the women that the police intend to continue prosecuting the matter and applying to the courts to amend the charges. I told you.
corresponding to age That same week, a spokesperson denied there had been “widespread issues related to the withdrawal of COVID-19-related charges or penalty notices” issued by Victoria Police.
Prosecutor Andrew Shim regretted the decision to drop charges against the women, but said the deputy sergeant who made the call did not have the authority to do so.
“There is no big conspiracy here about illegal activities or political decisions,” he told the court. “It was someone’s mistake to think that they should have submitted when they didn’t.”
Sim opposed Gerry’s request for access to the documents, telling the court that the files were in various prosecutor’s offices across the state and had to be reviewed on an individual basis.
“It’s a fishing practice,” he said. “Fishing in a lake where there may be no fish.”
But Gary said Victoria Police had already committed to review breach notices issued for violations of the Chief Health Officer’s directives to ensure consistency, and that the process was independent and broad. It was overseen by the Anti-Corruption Commission.
Justice of the Peace Andrew McKenna said charges were not formally dropped until the matter was brought to court, adding that decisions are often made before final results are available.
He denied access to the documents on the grounds that they served no legitimate forensic purpose, were partly subject to legal prerogative, and that the effort required to obtain police files was “oppressive.” I refused.
“This is an astounding amount of extensive material in light of the past three years of living with the pandemic and the many circumstances that have caused people to be prosecuted for one way or another violating the directives of the Chief Health Officer.” He said.
“In my view, it is clear that the applicant’s pursuit of it will fail.”
Gerry has 30 days to appeal the decision. The matter will be returned to the Melbourne Magistrates Court in early October for special mention.
The Morning Edition newsletter is your guide to the day’s most important and interesting articles, analysis and insights. SIGN UP HERE.
Prosecutor told rally organizers accusations were ‘fatally flawed’
Source link Prosecutor told rally organizers accusations were ‘fatally flawed’